Skip to content
Verdiktum

Comet 3I Atlas likely originated in a planetary system with completely different...

Piotr Kosek: "Comet 3I Atlas likely originated in a planetary system with completely different physical conditions, such as lower temperatures or a differ..." — Pending

P

📅 12.03.2026 · 3I/ATLAS: Międzygwiezdny gość pełen alkoholu - AstroKaw... · 👁️ 12

Pending. The claim that comet 3I Atlas likely originated in a planetary system with completely different physical conditions is inconsistent with the facts. Comet C/2019 Y4 (ATLAS), to which the author likely refers, is not an in...

"Comet 3I Atlas likely originated in a planetary system with completely different physical conditions, such as lower temperatures or a different chemical composition than the one that produced our comets. And to create such different conditions, it's enough, for example, for the star to be of a different type, and we will already have different temperatures at different distances, because less radiation, for example, will reach it. Or if the star is hotter, then more such radiation can reach it. It will be different for red dwarfs, different for yellow ones, like our sun." "Kometa 3I Atlas prawdopodobnie powstała w układzie planetarnym o zupełnie innych warunkach fizycznych, takich jak niższe temperatury lub inny skład chemiczny niż ten, który wytworzył nasze komety. A żeby wywołać takie inne warunki, to wystarczy chociażby, że gwiazda jest innego typu i już będziemy mieli na różnych odległościach różne chociażby temperatury, bo mniej na przykład promieniowania będzie docierało. Albo jeżeli gwiazda jest goręcza, no to więcej na przykład takiego promieniowania może docierać. Co innego będzie przy czerwonych karłach, co innego przy żółtych, takich jak nasze słoneczko."
🌐 (Machine-translated — original in Polish) · Original in Polishuage
🌐 Scenario 🔬 Technology AI confidence (unresolved): 100% Resolves by: 2031 🌐 jeśli gwiazda jest innego typu Assertiveness: medium 🌍 Global Source on YouTube

Source (proof)

Plays from the quoted moment

Verification

Analysis generated with AI Pro
Available in the Pro plan Full AI analysis, sources, counterarguments Unlock Pro
🤖
AI-generated analysis: This result is an assessment by a language model, not an expert opinion or a legally binding verdict. Verify sources before making any decisions. Model: gemini-2.5-flash

For informational purposes only. Not investment, financial, legal or tax advice. Full disclaimer

AI is analyzing your argument…

Community Arguments (AI Feedback)

Log in to use this feature

Login

Transcript excerpt

Oryginał w języku Polskim Open on YouTube

zymianie robią, resztę roboty robi dłuższy czas naświetlania. Teraz telefony mogą wiele sekund naświetlać. No to fajnie, to fajnie wiedzieć, że to nie jest po prostu namalowane przez jakiś tam algorytm tylko i tyle. Czy to będzie widoczne nieuzbrojonym okiem? Ale co w sensie, czy będzie niewidoczne Zorza, czy Droga Mleczna? To też jest pytanie w sumie do Mateusza. On był w jednym z najciemniejszych miejsc na ziemi w Namibii, w na tej astrofarmie. I no wiadomo, że aparatem zrobisz dużo więcej, bo zbierze on więcej fotonów, jest w stanie dłużej, no naświetlać, tak, łapać więcej tych fotonów niż

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first!

Sign in to leave a comment.

Related claims by Piotr Kosek

Piotr Kosek Piotr Kosek 13.02.2026
Pending
"We are entering the Vera Rubin Observatory, and it will be a true game changer, because we are launching a telescope with the largest digital camera in human history, 3.2 gigapixels. This monster will not look at a single point, but will scan the entire sky, constantly creating a time-lapse film of the universe's existence. The LSST program, or Legacy Survey of Space and Time, will generate 20 TB of data every night. Mike Brown said directly: "If someone gave him a suitcase full of money and told him to find Planet Nine, he would build something like the Vera Rubin telescope." This device is capable of detecting objects orders of magnitude dimmer than anything we have had so far. Scientists estimate that the number of known objects in the solar system will increase by as much as a hundredfold thanks to it. If Planet Nine is there, Vera Rubin will find it. If it's the Kuiper Belt disk, Vera Rubin will see its structure. "
translated PL · original
🔮 Forecast Technology 2026
Piotr Kosek Piotr Kosek 25.03.2026
Failed
"We will not wait another six decades for confirmation of which candidate is the correct one. In March 2026, the Indian orbiter Chandrayaan 2 will fly directly over the selected area. This flight is part of an ongoing lunar surface mapping project, so that in the future we know where everything is. "
translated PL · original
🔮 Forecast Technology 2026
Piotr Kosek Piotr Kosek 08.04.2026
Fulfilled
"The landing will most likely take place in '28, '29. And here the Chinese are hot on the heels of the Americans. They don't really boast about every point of the program, like the Americans, but quietly pursue their goal and also want to get to the moon. Why? Because on the Moon there are few places where water is potentially located at the south pole. And these are great places because we have craters there, where some of these craters are practically always shielded from sunlight, so for billions of years there have actually been ice deposits. It may seem strange, what kind of raw material ice is, but ice in space is, one might say, the most valuable raw material. We have oxygen there, we have hydrogen there, because it is frozen water, so by extracting this ice we can have fuel, we can have oxygen for breathing, we can have water, which is also needed for everything, no matter how you look at it. So this is a very important place on the Moon, and in such places, where on one side we have this ice in the depths of the crater, and on the other side, on the top, on the edges of this crater, we have a place where for 90% of the time, sometimes even 100% of the time, we have sunlight. well, we can install a base and... "
translated PL · original
🔮 Forecast Technology 2029
Piotr Kosek Piotr Kosek 14.06.2026
Fulfilled
"Future astronomers, who will be born on planets around our dying stars in 100 or 200 billion years, will look at the night sky and see absolutely nothing beyond the stars of their own galaxy. "
translated PL · original
🔮 Forecast Catastrophes 2041